ABSTRACT
Objective To investigate the application value of choledochoscopy and imaging examination in the diagnosis and treatment of residual bile duct stones.Methods The retrospective descriptive study was conducted.The clinical data of 618 patients who underwent choledochoscopy and imaging examination after operation of hepatolithiasis in the First Affiliated Hospital of Zhengzhou University between April 2014 and September 2018 were collected,including 300 males and 318 females,aged from 19 to 89 years,with an average age of (58 ± 12)years.Observation indicators:(1) situations of residual bile duct stones diagnosed by choledochoscopy and imaging examination;(2) stone extraction situations of patients with hepatolithiasis.Measurement data with normal distribution were represented as Mean±SD,and measurement data with skewed distribution were described as M (range).Count data were represented as absolute number or percentage,and analyzed using the chi-square test or Fisher exact propability.Results (1) Situations of residual bile duct stones diagnosed by choledochoscopy and imaging examination:all the 618 patients underwent choledochoscopy,and 505 of them underwent the imaging examination before choledochoscopy.① Of patients undergoing single imaging examination,72 received ultrasonography,with false-negative rate of 29.17％ (21/72);37 received CT examination,with false-negative rate of 10.81％(4/37);33 received T-tube cholangiography,with false-negative rate of 39.39％ (13/33).② Of patients undergoing combined two imaging examinations,61 received ultrasonography + CT,with false-negative rate of 8.20％ (5/61);129 received ultrasonography + T-tube cholangiography,with false-negative rate of 12.40％ (16/129);52 received CT + T-tube cholangiography,with false-negative rate of 5.77％(3/52).③ There were 121 receiving ultrasound+CT+T-tube cholangiography,with false-negative rate of 7.44％ (9/121).There were statistically significant differences in the false-negative rates of combined two or three examinations of ultrasound + CT+ T-tube cholangiography and single imaging examination (x2=40.83,P＜0.05).The further analysis showed a statistically significant difference among the single imaging examination (x2=7.70,P＜0.05).There was no statistically significant difference among the combined two of imaging examinations (x2=2.10,P＞0.05).There were statistically significant differences in the combined three examinations of ultrasound +CT+T-tube cholangiography and ultrasound and T-tube cholangiography examination respectively (x2=16.23,21.62,P＜0.05).There was no statistically significant difference in the combined three of imaging examinations and CT examination and combination of CT+T-tube cholangiography respectively (P＞ 0.05).There was no statistically significant difference in the combined three of imaging examinations and combination of ultrasound+CT examinations and combination of ultrasound+T-tube cholangiography (x2=0.33,1.71,P＞0.05).Seventy-one patients without residual bile duct stone by preoperative imaging examination were detected residual bile duct stones by intraoperative choledochoscopy,and residual bile duct stones of 36,31 and 4 patients are respectively distributed around the distal common bile duct,small intrahepatic bile duct,left and right hepatic ducts,common hepatic duct and remaining common bile duct.(2) Stone extraction situations of patients with hepatolithiasis:of 618 patients,cases with 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,8,9 and 10 times of residual bile duct stones clearance were respectively 392,116,48,39,9,6,3,2,2 and 1.Residual bile duct stones clearance frequency of patients was an average of 1.73 times.There were 63.43％(392/618) and 96.28％(595/618) of patients had stone clearance with once and ≤ 4 times of stone extraction,respectively.Conclusion The negative results of preoperative imaging examinations cannot be as standards of bile duct stone clearance before choledochoscopy,and the best choice is to detect whether there are residual bile duct stones and remove the stones combined with choledochoscopy.